Ideal weight or BMI? Which one to rely on, and why

Published · A single number or a healthy range?

You search for "my ideal weight" and one website says 65 kg while another says 61, then you work out your body mass index and it says any weight between 53 and 72 is "healthy". All these numbers are arithmetically correct, but they answer different questions. This article explains where each number comes from, and when to rely on it.

Ideal weight formulas: one number from height alone

The best known is the Devine formula (1974): for men, 50 kg + 2.3 kg for each inch over 5 feet (152.4 cm); for women, 45.5 kg + 2.3 kg for each inch. It was originally designed to work out doses of some medicines, then spread as if it were "the ideal weight". Other formulas with slightly different factors followed, so their results differ for the same height:

Formula (height 170 cm)ManWoman
Devine65.9 kg61.4 kg
Robinson65.2 kg60.8 kg
Miller66.0 kg62.5 kg
Hamwi66.7 kg60.7 kg

Notice that the formulas differ by between one and a half and five kilos depending on height (for a woman 160 cm tall they give 52.1 to 57.2 kg), and that all of them ignore age, body build and muscle. So it's more accurate to treat this number as a point in the middle of a range, not a target to hit to the kilo.

BMI: a healthy range instead of a single number

BMI = weight in kilograms ÷ (height in metres)². The World Health Organization counts the range from 18.5 to 24.9 as a healthy weight for adults. Turning the formula around gives the healthy weight range for any height: the minimum = 18.5 × height², and the maximum = 24.9 × height².

HeightApproximate healthy weight range
155 cm44.4 – 59.8 kg
160 cm47.4 – 63.7 kg
165 cm50.4 – 67.8 kg
170 cm53.5 – 72.0 kg
175 cm56.7 – 76.3 kg
180 cm59.9 – 80.7 kg
185 cm63.3 – 85.2 kg

The ideal weight figures for a height of 170 cm (61–67 kg) all fall inside the BMI range (53.5–72), so the two methods don't contradict each other: the formula gives you a point, and BMI gives you the safe area around it.

Which one should you rely on?

A simple third measure: waist size

Neither number knows where your fat is stored. That's why a simple measure is often used: your waist should be less than half your height. For a height of 170 cm, the limit is about 85 cm. Someone who is 180 cm tall and weighs 90 kg has a BMI of 27.8 (overweight), but if their waist is under 90 cm and they have a lot of muscle, they may be in better shape than their BMI suggests.

Work it out yourself

Enter your weight and height in the BMI calculator to see your category and the healthy weight range for your height straight away. If your goal is to get inside that range, find out your daily needs with the calorie calculator, and read how many calories to cut a day to lose half a kilo a week.

This article is general education, not a diagnosis or medical prescription. A healthy weight depends on age, health and body composition; talk to your doctor or a dietitian before any programme to lose or gain weight.

Also read: BMI for children: why the adult calculator doesn't work

Related tools