You work out your child's body mass index and get a number like 19, compare it with the adult table and feel reassured because it's "healthy". The problem is that this comparison isn't valid for children. In this article we explain why adult categories don't work for children, and how to read the result the right way.
The same formula, read differently
The calculation itself doesn't change: weight in kilograms divided by the square of height in metres. A child who weighs 30 kg and is 125 cm tall:
BMI = 30 ÷ (1.25 × 1.25) = about 19.2.
For adults, this number falls in the "healthy weight" category, which runs from 18.5 to 24.9. For children there are no fixed limits like these, because the amount of body fat changes naturally as a child grows, and it differs between boys and girls. So a number that counts as healthy for an adult may be high for an eight-year-old, and may be fine for a sixteen-year-old.
How is the result read for children?
For children and teenagers, the number is compared with others of the same age and sex using growth charts, and the result is given as a "percentile". The percentile is the child's position among 100 children of their age and sex: the 70th percentile means their BMI is higher than about 70% of them.
The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) uses the following categories for ages 2 to 19:
| Percentile for age and sex | Category |
|---|---|
| Below the 5th percentile | Underweight |
| 5th to below the 85th percentile | Healthy weight |
| 85th to below the 95th percentile | Overweight |
| 95th percentile or above | Obesity |
The World Health Organization uses a similar method based on how far the child is from the average for their age and sex. Either way, the conclusion is the same: the number alone isn't enough, and it has to be compared with the right growth chart.
Why not use the adult calculator for your child?
- Fixed limits are misleading: a "healthy" result may reassure you while the child is on a high percentile, or an "underweight" result may worry you while they're in a healthy range for their age.
- Growth isn't steady: a child may suddenly get taller and then put on weight, so the reading swings from month to month. What matters is the direction of the curve over time, not a single reading.
- Differences between boys and girls become clear around puberty, and the adult calculator doesn't take them into account.
That's why the Hisba BMI calculator points out that its categories are for adults and don't apply to children.
What to do in practice
- Measure height and weight accurately: the child without shoes and in light clothes, and their height standing with their back against a wall. A 2 cm error in height changes the result noticeably.
- Record the readings with their dates every few months, because the trend matters more than the number.
- Show the readings to your paediatrician or at a growth check-up. They'll plot them on the right growth chart and read them alongside the child's health history.
- Don't put your child on a diet yourself. Cutting a child's food without supervision can affect their growth. The focus is usually on the whole family's habits: the type of food, sugary drinks, sleep and activity.
When to see a doctor soon
- Height stops increasing, or weight drops for no clear reason.
- A big, sudden jump in weight within a few months.
- Constant tiredness, heavy snoring during sleep, or frequent comments from the child about their looks and eating.
This article is for general awareness and doesn't replace an assessment by a paediatrician. Classifying a child's weight needs growth charts by age and sex, and a specialist's reading of their health history.