You see an ad for "personal finance at just 4%", and another for "home finance at 6%". The first looks much cheaper, but comparing them that way can be completely wrong, because the two numbers aren't calculated the same way. The difference between a flat rate and a reducing rate can nearly double the cost of your financing.
The flat rate
It's charged on the full amount for the whole term, even after you've repaid a large part of it. Example: 50,000 riyals over 3 years at a 5% flat rate:
- Profit = 50,000 × 5% × 3 = 7,500 riyals.
- Total repayment = 57,500 riyals, and the instalment = 57,500 ÷ 36 = 1,597.22 riyals.
The reducing rate
It's charged each month on the remaining balance only. In the first month you pay profit on the full amount, then the profit falls with every instalment because the balance falls. This is the usual method for home finance, and it's what the annual percentage rate (APR) expresses.
The right comparison: the APR
To compare two offers, convert the flat rate into its reducing-rate equivalent. In the example above, an instalment of 1,597.22 riyals for 36 months on 50,000 is equivalent to a reducing rate of about 9.31%, not 5%.
| Flat rate | Term | Approximate reducing-rate equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| 4% | 5 years | 7.42% |
| 5% | 3 years | 9.31% |
The rule of thumb: a flat rate is equivalent to nearly double as a reducing rate, and the gap narrows slightly as the term gets longer. That's why a "4% flat" offer can cost more than a "6% reducing" offer.
A longer term: a lighter instalment and a higher cost
Stretching the term lowers the monthly instalment, but with a flat rate it raises the total profit a lot, because the profit is multiplied by the number of years:
| 50,000 riyals at 5% flat | 3 years | 5 years |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly instalment | 1,597.22 | 1,041.67 |
| Total profit | 7,500 | 12,500 |
| Approximate reducing-rate equivalent | 9.31% | 9.15% |
Choose the shortest term your income can comfortably handle, and don't stretch it just because the instalment looks smaller.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Is the advertised rate flat or reducing? And what is the APR?
- How much are the admin fees? Is there compulsory insurance added to the instalment?
- What is the early settlement amount if you pay off the loan after a year or two?
- Does the instalment fit your budget? A common rule of thumb is that all your instalments together shouldn't exceed a third of your net salary.
Work it out yourself
Enter the finance offer in the loan and instalment calculator and choose the type of rate. It shows you the instalment, the profit and the effective rate equivalent to a flat rate.
The examples are for illustration and don't include admin fees or insurance. This article is general financial education, not financial advice; check the lender's terms before you sign.
Also read: the 50/30/20 rule for splitting your salary, and how to work out a car finance instalment